Skip to main content

Crime increased in areas trialling cashless debit card programs, government analysis suggests

Coalition claims scrapping cards could lead to ‘tsunami of trauma’ but federal department analysis of available data paints a different picture


Crime rates have increased or remained steady in regions hosting cashless debit card programs, according to the department of social services, as the Albanese government prepares to abolish the controversial welfare program within weeks.

Critics of the government’s decision have claimed the card’s axing would increase crime and alcohol abuse, but the department has claimed its analysis of police data has shown total crime rates, assault and property damage have gone up in areas where the income management tool was being trialled.

Labor promised during the election campaign to abolish the cashless debit card, which quarantines between 30% and 80% of welfare payments and was designed to prevent money being withdrawn as cash or used to pay for alcohol or gambling. A bill to scrap the card passed the House of Representatives earlier this month and was set to pass through the Senate after most of the crossbench said they would support the repeal. After numerous hearings in recent weeks, a Senate inquiry was due to release its report on Friday. The opposition has strongly opposed Labor’s plan, with the shadow social services minister, Michael Sukkar, claiming the abolition would lead to a “tsunami of trauma”.

But a department analysis of publicly available data from state police services showed crime in cashless debit card trial sites like Ceduna, Alice Springs and Bundaberg had increased in recent years. In the Bundaberg and Hervey Bay region, which had 6,464 cashless debit card participants as of 29 July, the department claimed crime rates increased by 12% between 2020 and 2021.

In Ceduna, with 1,095 participants, the crime rate increased 22% between 2020 and 2021.

Across the Northern Territory, where the entire jurisdiction was hosting the cashless debit card program, the department claimed assault and other crimes had increased over the life of the program.

The analysis found Alice Springs, with 398 participants, had the highest increase in crime across the NT in 2021.  The abolition of the cashless debit card would not affect the basics card, a separate income management tool used by thousands of welfare recipients in the NT. The social services minister, Amanda Rishworth, has flagged further discussion later this year on other forms of income management.  In evidence to Senate hearings in recent weeks, participants and community advocates had warned crime rates had remained steady or increased during the cashless debit card program.

Beverly Walley, a Noongar Ballardong woman, told a hearing on Monday of the impact in the east Kimberley region.

“There’s been a lot of frustration, anger, domestic violence, kids not going to school,” she said.

“There has always been youth crime. There had always been parents drinking, drugs and gambling prior to the cashless card being enforced in 2015-16. Having said that, there is no change. Everything is still the same.”

Christine Donaldson, a cashless debit card participant and Wangkatha Ngadju elder from the Goldfields region, said the program had “increased crime, racism, elder abuse, alcohol and drug abuse, and self-harming”.  The deputy chief executive of the Western Australia Council of Social Services (WACOSS) and former Greens senator, Rachel Siewert, gave similar testimony to a hearing last week.

“In my opinion, and in WACOSS’s opinion, you can’t say there has been a decrease in crime due to the cashless debit card,” she said.  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Government to take greater control of Liverpool city council

Intervention expanded to include financial decisions and governance after report calls for urgent reform.  The government’s intervention in the running of Liverpool city council is to be expanded to include governance and financial decision-making. It comes after the publication of another critical report on the local authority by four commissioners appointed last year to work with the council staff in key areas after an inspection. The report, published on Friday and addressed to the communities secretary, Greg Clark, said certain services were “failing” and in need of “urgent reform”. It warns that poor performance in procurement, finance and auditing are limiting the “council’s ability to operate at a crucial time” and called for an added role of “finance commissioner”.  It comes after a report in June revealed that Liverpool city council’s failure to renew contracts across a number of services could cost it millions. Clark, in a letter to the commissioners, rai...
Post a Comment
Read more

German chancellor speaks with Israeli PM Lapid following Abbas Holocaust remark in Berlin

German Chancellor Olaf Scholz spoke to Israeli Prime Minister Yair Lapid on Thursday, addressing remarks about the Holocaust made by Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas during a recent visit to Berlin. Scholz had tweeted on Wednesday that Abbas's claim that Israel has committed "50 Holocausts" against Palestinians was "intolerable and unacceptable." He then wanted to address it directly with Lapid, who is the son of Holocaust survivors. "At the start of their conversation, the German Chancellor emphasized that he rejects and condemns Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas’s remarks, and that it was important for him to clarify this personally to the Prime Minister, as well as publicly," Lapid's office said in a press release about their conversation.  "I thanked him for this condemnation as Israel’s Prime Minister and the son of a Holocaust survivor," Lapid said in a tweet acknowledging the conversation. The two...
Post a Comment
Read more

Just Stop Oil protesters block service stations on M25 in second day of action

Environmental activists take action at Cobham services in Surrey, Clacket Lane in Kent and Thurrock in Essex Environmental protesters have blocked three service stations on the M25 in a second day of action this week attempting to put pressure on the government to end new oil and gas projects. According to the Just Stop Oil campaign, 32 of its supporters took action from 5am at Cobham services in Surrey, Clacket Lane services in Kent and Thurrock services in Essex. They blocked access to petrol pumps by sitting in the road with banners, while some sabotaged petrol pumps by breaking the display glass, covering them with spray paint or locking on to them. Surrey police said their officers made 20 arrests after attending Cobham and Clacket Lane services. Cobham has reopened, with limited access to petrol, but Clacket Lane remained closed in both directions owing to damage to pumps. Just Stop Oil said the protest was intended to “put further pressure on petrol and diesel suppli...
Post a Comment
Read more